SCOTUS WOTUS Arguments Reaction

The National Cattlemen’s Beef Association is calling for a pause in the EPA rewriting of Trump-era WOTUS reforms until the Supreme Court settles the confusion over the Environmental Protection Agency’s power to regulate water bodies under the Clean Water Act.

“Regulatory whiplash” is how National Cattlemen describe the shifting WOTUS definitions over the years, as the Supreme Court this week again tried to make sense of the Clean Water Act. And until the High Court decides on a proper test for which waters are “Waters of the US,” Cattlemen CEO Colin Woodall is calling for a pause in EPA WOTUS rulemaking

Woodall said; “After all the work we did to fight back against the 2015 rule, here we have the Biden Administration coming out and trying once again to bring WOTUS back.”

At the Supreme Court, the test for EPA jurisdiction over an Idaho home lot near a lake was still unclear. This exchange between government lawyer Brian Fletcher and Chief Justice John Roberts. “So, somebody looking around the lot would have to look at the wetlands, if they could see them, and the lake and say, ‘is that reasonable proximity, or not?’” Fletcher “Yes, that’s right, that is the standard.” Roberts “That’s a standard that’s used in criminal prosecutions, as well.”

With the wry hint that the government could prosecute a landowner if they got it wrong. Longtime Iowa Senator Chuck Grassley calls for a traditional standard that covers only wetlands connected to navigable waters, not features like a usually dry creek. Grassley; “Ridiculous. So, the best thing to do is to go with the historic definition of a navigable river. That’s where the federal jurisdiction ends, and that’s where the state jurisdiction takes over.”

An argument akin to that of the plaintiffs in the long-running Sacketts vs. the U.S. EPA – “nearby versus directly connected” – and a case Grassley and NCBA say the Supreme Court must finally resolve for the sake of homeowners, farmers, and others.

Related articles

Friday, December 2nd, 2022 Video and Audio Program

A busy week of trade and a volatile Friday session calls for a jam packed program to wrap up the week! First up, we are joined by DuWayne Bosse of Bolt Marketing to discuss the...

EPA Proposes RFS Volumes for 2023-2025 With Modest Boost for Conventional Ethanol; Not Everyone is Happy

The EPA is finally out with proposed Renewable Fuel Standard volumes for 2023 through 2025, and the ethanol industry is mostly pleased. “A clear pathway for sustainable growth” and an “upward trajectory” for clean...

NCBA Applauds Protect Farmers from the SEC ACT in Senate

The National Cattlemen’s Beef Association supports the Senate version of the Protect Farmers from the SEC Act, a companion bill to legislation introduced into the House of Representatives by Oklahoma Republican Frank Lucas. “The Securities...

USDA Expands Revenue Protection for Oat and Rye Producers

The country’s oat and rye producers can now benefit from revenue protection, a new crop insurance option available through the USDA. After listening to growers, the Risk Management Agency expanded the Small Grains Crop...

2022 Has Been a Challenge for Cattle Producers

Acknowledging every year has its ups and its down, Cameron Mulrony says 2022 was a challenging year for local cattle producers to say the least. Mulrony, the Executive Vice President of the Idaho Cattle Association...

Latest articles

%d bloggers like this: